A Rare Meniscus Transplant Surgery Gives A Young Girl A New Lease On Life
Most surgeons are well versed in treatments for the painful damaged knee cartilage that typically affects older adults after years of wear and tear. When a young patient suffers cartilage damage, treatment is delicate and requires the specialized expertise offered at Summit Orthopedics.
“Children aren’t supposed to have joint problems,” observes Dr. Jack Skendzel. “But by the time I examined the swollen, painful knee of our young patient, she had undergone three knee surgeries with other surgeons—without improvement. She had a rare congenital condition called discoid meniscus, which made the cushioning cartilage in her knee thicker than normal and more prone to injury.”
Although corrective arthroscopic surgery procedures can reshape and repair a discoid meniscus, multiple attempts to repair and then trim out torn tissue left this patient with very little healthy meniscus remaining in her knee. “Meniscal cartilage has a limited blood supply, which complicates the healing process,” Dr. Skendzel explains. “After three surgeries, the meniscus was in poor shape. Our young patient was still in pain, and in danger of developing early arthritis.”
Dr. Skendzel and Dr. James Gannon collaborated to develop a treatment plan; the options require patients to weigh some complicated risks and benefits—especially in this case, where the patient was so young, and had so many potentially active years ahead of her.
Total knee replacement is an excellent option for older patients with significant cartilage damage, but it’s not an ideal option for younger, active individuals. A knee replacement has a limited life span. This is not a significant concern for a 65-year-old, but Drs. Skendzel and Gannon knew that their young patient would probably need a new joint replacement in her 30s or earlier; they also knew that secondary replacements are rarely as successful.
Another option was to consider a meniscus transplant, but delay it until the age of 15 or 16, when their patient had stopped growing. In this procedure, a meniscus that matches the size and shape of the patient’s knee is transplanted to restore the shock-absorbing effect of the meniscus and help prevent early damage to the smooth articular cartilage. Waiting would reduce the risk of growth plate damage. Growth plates are the areas of bone tissue at the ends of long bones that are still developing in childhood. A surgical delay would protect the growth plates, but meant years of additional pain. In addition, if arthritis developed in the meantime, their patient would be ineligible for a transplant.
Drs. Skendzel and Gannon discussed the options with their patient, and decided to proceed with a meniscus transplant. The surgery carried risks, as every surgery does. Even if the transplant was successful, the transplanted tissue may tear. There is a risk of knee stiffness and failure of the graft to heal. Rehabilitation takes time and involves commitment to a long program of physical therapy to reclaim mobility.
“In this case,” Dr. Gannon says, “a transplant was the right option. Our patient is no longer in pain, the transplant and rehabilitation have gone beautifully, and this young woman can look forward to a full and active life. She is delighted, and so are we.”
Summit Orthopedics offers comprehensive sports medicine expertise
From Olympians to pro athletes to kids in youth sports and those that just want to be more active—Summit Orthopedics delivers expert care by fellowship-trained sports medicine physicians. If you are recently injured or concerned about ongoing pain, Summit Orthopedics sports medicine specialists have the expertise to evaluate your discomfort and develop a plan to quickly and safely help you get back to being active.
Summit has convenient locations across the Minneapolis-St. Paul metro area, serving Minnesota and western Wisconsin. We have state-of-the-art centers for comprehensive orthopedic care in Eagan, MN, Vadnais Heights, MN, Plymouth, MN, and Woodbury, MN, as well as several additional community clinics.
More resources for you
- Dr. Forseth discusses giving back through medical mission scholarships at One World Surgery Center in Honduras
- Dr. Skendzel Explains Rotator Cuff Surgery
- Do You Have An Unstable Kneecap?
- Ask Dr. Skendzel: What Are Surgical Options For Unstable Kneecaps?
- Ask Dr. Skendzel: What Can I Expect After Knee Cartilage Surgery?
“An active lifestyle requires superior physical function, and I understand that my patients have exceptionally high standards for their performance and joint health. My goal is to return patients to optimal function so that they can continue to perform and master their personal athletic goals.”
Summit hand and upper extremity surgeon — and enthusiastic fly fisherman — J.P. Delaney, M.D., tells you what you need to know about fishing if you’re concerned about hand, wrist, or shoulder injury.
As an elite athlete, Maggie Nichols suffered many different types of injuries during her gymnastics career and she always had a home at Summit Orthopedics. From injections to surgeries to physical therapy, listen how Summit impacted her career and kept her competing at the highest level.
We asked Matthew Nies, M.D., one of Summit’s knee replacement specialists, what his patients ask most about total knee replacement.